UM  > Faculty of Social Sciences  > DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNICATION
Residential Collegefalse
Total-Effect Test is Superfluous for Establishing Complementary Mediation
Yingkai Jiang1; Xinshu Zhao2; Lixing Zhu3; Jun S. Liu4; Ke Deng1
Source PublicationStatistica Sinica

Mediation, which in social science literature means that an independent variable Xaffects a dependent variable Y through a mediator M, is a key concept in causal inference. For establishing mediation via data analysis, there is a long debate in the literature on whether we still require the “total effect” of X on Y to be statistically significant, given the significance of both the “mediated effect” and the “direct effect” ofX on Y . In the last decade, it has been shown and widely accepted that total-effect test can erroneously reject “indirect-only mediation” and “competitive mediation” and should not be applied to establish mediation of these two types. For “complementary mediation”, however, the situation becomes more complicated and no consensus is reached so far. This article provides an explicit proof that the total effect has to be statistically significant whenever mediated effect and direct effect bear the same sign and are both significant, as long as the least square estimation (LSE) and F-tests are used to estimate and test mediation effects. We also show that the similar result can be obtained when the Sobel test is used in the place of the F-test. Our results support the growing consensus that the total-effect test should be abolished for establishing mediation.

KeywordComplementary Mediation Hypothesis Testing Linear Model Mediation Analysis Total-effect Test
Document TypeJournal article
Affiliation1.Tsinghua University
2.University of Macau
3.Hong Kong Baptist University
4.Harvard University
Recommended Citation
GB/T 7714
Yingkai Jiang,Xinshu Zhao,Lixing Zhu,et al. Total-Effect Test is Superfluous for Establishing Complementary Mediation[J]. Statistica Sinica,2020.
APA Yingkai Jiang,Xinshu Zhao,Lixing Zhu,Jun S. Liu,&Ke Deng.(2020).Total-Effect Test is Superfluous for Establishing Complementary Mediation.Statistica Sinica.
MLA Yingkai Jiang,et al."Total-Effect Test is Superfluous for Establishing Complementary Mediation".Statistica Sinica (2020).
Files in This Item: Download All
File Name/Size Publications Version Access License
Total-effect test is(2100KB)期刊论文作者接受稿开放获取CC BY-NC-SAView Download
2019-0150_0326.pdf(2662KB)期刊论文出版稿开放获取CC BY-NC-SAView Download
Related Services
Recommend this item
Usage statistics
Export to Endnote
Google Scholar
Similar articles in Google Scholar
[Yingkai Jiang]'s Articles
[Xinshu Zhao]'s Articles
[Lixing Zhu]'s Articles
Baidu academic
Similar articles in Baidu academic
[Yingkai Jiang]'s Articles
[Xinshu Zhao]'s Articles
[Lixing Zhu]'s Articles
Bing Scholar
Similar articles in Bing Scholar
[Yingkai Jiang]'s Articles
[Xinshu Zhao]'s Articles
[Lixing Zhu]'s Articles
Terms of Use
No data!
Social Bookmark/Share
File name: Total-effect test is superflous for establishing complementary mediation.pdf
Format: Adobe PDF
This file does not support browsing at this time
File name: 2019-0150_0326.pdf
Format: Adobe PDF
All comments (0)
No comment.

Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.